Music 343—Encounter 6
Baroque II:  Mid-Baroque
Baroque III:  Late Baroque Masters
Readings
I. Group Presentation 6
II. Final Paper Peer Review
Listening Assignment 6
Extra Credit Listening
Baroque Sonata Listening Guide
Guide to Baroque Vocal Music
Due Dates: Part I due on the date of your presentation
                   Part II due on Monday, December 7, 2020

What to hand in for Encounter 6?—

  • Part I: A one-page summary of your presentation notes and a bibliography in MLA format with at least six sources (due on the day of the presentation).
  • Part II: Two reviews of your final paper first draft by two other students in this course, and your reviews of final paper first drafts sent to you by two other students in this course.
  • Listening: Nothing to hand in for the listening assignment. The Final Exam will test you on this material.

Readings—

  • Burkholder, J. Peter, A History of Western Music, 10th edition
    • Chapter 15: Music for Chamber and Church in the Early Seventeenth Century, pp. 317-325
    • Chapter 16: France, England, Spain, the New World, and Russia in the Seventeenth Century, pp. 339-370
    • Chapter 17: Italy and Germany in the Late Seventeenth Century, pp. 371-399
    • Part Four: The Eighteenth Century, pp. 400-401
    • Chapter 18: The Early Eighteenth Century in Italy and France, pp. 402-423
    • Chapter 19: German Composers of the Late Baroque, pp. 424-453
    • Chapter 21: Opera and Vocal Music in the Early Classic Period, pp. 471-486
  • Burkholder, J. Peter, Norton Anthology of Western Music, 8th edition, Vol. 1 (NAWM)
    • NAWM 77, 80, & 85-108: pp. 539-548, 582-595, & 629-942
  • Burkholder, J. Peter, Norton Anthology of Western Music, 8th edition, Vol. 2 (NAWM)
    • NAWM 109-112
  • David, Hans and Arthur Mendel, eds., The Bach Reader (RESERVE)
  • Le Huray, Peter, Authenticity in Performance: Eighteenth-Century Case Studies (Blackboard RESERVE)
    • Chapter 3, “Corelli’s Violin Sonata Op. 5 No. 11,” pp. 24-44
  • Mattheson, Johann, Der vollkommene Kapellmeister (RESERVE)
    • Part I, Chapter 3, Sections 49-83, pp. 103-110
    • Part II, Chapter 13, Sections 79-142, pp. 451-468
Sources on Baroque performance practice
  • Sadie, Julie, ed. Companion to Baroque Music. University of California Press, 1998 (available via interlibrary loan or google.books). The five chapters listed below will be especially helpful for this project.
    • Mangsen, Sandra, “Forms and Genres: The Chamber: sonata, suite, and concerto,” pp. 394-400
    • Schott, Howard, “National Styles,” pp. 409-416
    • Fuller, David, “Ornamentation,” pp. 417-434
    • Montague, Jeremy, “Instruments,” pp. 366-375
    • Sadie, Stanley, “The Idea of Authenticity,” pp. 435-446
  • Donington, Robert. Baroque Music: Style and Performance—A Handbook. W.W. Norton, 1982 (on RESERVE)
  • In addition to Sadie and Donington, you can find good sources on performance practice on RESERVE

Return to top


I. Group Presentation 6
Baroque Vocal Music

Here are the five pieces from NAWM (Norton Anthology of Western Music) for the Encounter 6 group presentations.
  • Group INAWM 90a & 90b, Purcell, Dido and Aeneas - Thy hand, Belinda & When I am laid in earth—Wednesday, November 25
    • Close Analysis—NAWM 90b, When I am laid in earth
  • Group IINAWM 85a, Lully, Armide - Ouverture—Monday, November 30
  • Group IIINAWM 106c, d, & e, Bach, St. Matthew Passion - No. 38. Petrus aber saß draußen im Palast, No. 39. Erbarme dich, & No. 40. Bin ich gleich von dir gewichen—Friday, December 4
    • Close Analysis—NAWM 106d, No. 39. Erbarme dich
  • Group IVNAWM 107b & 107c, Handel, Giulio Cesare - Act II, Scene 2. Da Cleopatra apprenda & V’adoro, pupille—Wednesday, December 9
    • Close Analysis—NAWM 107c, V’adoro, pupille
  • Group VNAWM 108a, b, & c, Handel, Saul - Act II, Scene 10. The Time at length is come, Where is the Son of Jesse?, & O fatal Consequence of Rage—Friday, December 11
    • Close Analysis—NAWM 108c, O fatal Consequence of Rage

Each group will give a 10-minute Powerpoint presentation on their assigned piece. Ideally, you will start an overview of the entire excerpt and then present the sections in order (in multi-section works). For most sections you will offer a brief description and play excerpts. For the section labeled “Close Analysis” you will provide detailed analysis and play the entire section. Each presentation will cover whatever seems most important, but be sure to include the following items.

Questions for every group:

  • Who is the composer?
  • Where would this music be performed?
  • Who would perform it? Who would be there to listen? Who would not be there?
  • Who would benefit or profit from the performance?
  • What function would this work serve in the performance context?
  • What is the genre?
    • Look up that genre in the Baroque Vocal Genres Listening Guide. Which features of your piece are typical of that genre?
    • How does this work compare with other works in the same genre?
    • What features of this work are unique or unusual?
  • Compare your score with the Baroque Opera Listening Guide. What types of vocal numbers are used in your NAWM excerpts (recitative? accompanied recitative? aria? chorus? etc.)? Which features in your score are typical of those vocal types?
  • What style is used?
  • How does this work use the elements of music?
    • Describe how this work uses melody, harmony, rhythm, dynamics, texture, color (timbre), form, text setting, and so on.
    • What is the key of your work? (What mode for Gabrieli?)
    • Which elements are typical of the style? Which are not?
  • Describe the form (sections, phrase relationships, and so on).
    • For your close analysis, it’s never a bad idea to include an analytical chart in your Powerpoint that shows each major section with the key and measure numbers for each. Browse through NAWM for examples of charts you can use as models.
  • Identify specific techniques used to depict or express the text.
  • What performances practices would be used in singing and/or playing this piece?
Questions on specific pieces:
  • Group I—For your close analysis, what features make When I am laid in earth a ground bass aria? Can this work be analyzed in binary form? Explain how. In the closing ritornello, what musical features express an extra degree of anguish?
  • Group II—Considering its form as well as contrasts in texture, tempo, meter, etc., what typical features of French overture form do you find in this work? What features of French Baroque performance practice can be heard?
  • Group III—For the Bach passion, how does Bach handle the passages labeled as “Biblical narrative”? What types of vocal writing does he blend in these passages? Does the chorus singing the chorale narrate the story, participate in the action, or reflect on the story?
    • For your close analysis of the aria, what makes this an obbligato aria? Analyze this as a da capo aria. Which features are typical of a da capo aria? Which are not?
  • Group IV—How does Handel combine recitative and aria in “scene complexes” like this one (see textbook pp. 445-446) in order to alter the “recit-aria-recit-aria-etc.” formula of previous Baroque operas? Specifically, what is the effect of Caesar’s frequent interruptions of Cleopatra’s entertainment?
    • For your close analysis of V’adoro, pupille, analyze this as a da capo aria. Which features are typical of a da capo aria? Which are not? What features of the sarabande can you find here? Why is that an appropriate choice for this scene?
  • Group V—What is the overall effect of Handel’s combination of accompanied recitative, simple recitative, and chorus in “scene complexes” like this one (see textbook pp. 445-446)?
    • For your close analysis of the chorus, analyze this much as you did Renaissance motets. How does Handel define the sections in this work, and how do we move from one section to another? Which sections are imitative? Which are homorhythmic? In your analysis, pay careful attention to the text and the techniques Handel uses to express the words.
Group members will take turns speaking, so each group will need to decide who is responsible for which of the questions above. Each group member will turn in a one-page outline of their presentation notes and their own bibliography in MLA format (individual bibliographies only, no group bibliographies!). Obvious sources include the textbook and NAWM. Find at least six sources total for your research. Highly recommended sources include:
  • an article from the New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians (Oxford/Grove Music Online)
  • relevant materials from the Readings list above
  • a period history (a comprehensive book covering the history of music in a particular era)
  • a book or article on Baroque performance practice
  • a scholarly journal article on your topic
  • books/ebooks that deal with your topic
You can include as many Grove Online articles as you like, but only one can count toward the six required sources.

One designated group member will email me the Powerpoint document on the day of the presentation.

Thinking about Elements of Music

  • Melody—high or low? moves by step or leap? wide or narrow range? regular or uneven phrase lengths? melodic shape and contour?
  • Texture—how many things going on simultaneously? monophonic? polyphonic (with imitation?)? homophonic (homorhythmic or melody & accompaniment?)?
  • Rhythm—clear beat or not? meter? tempo? rhythmic patterns? syncopation? how does time pass?
  • Color—specific instrumental colors? high, medium, or low register? interesting color combinations? overall color? articulation (legato, staccato, etc.)? attack, sustain, and decay characteristics?
  • Harmony—diatonic or chromatic? scale type? stable or unstable? simple (triads) or complex chords? consonant or dissonant?
  • Dynamics—loud or soft? accents? sudden or gradual changes?
  • Form—repetition? contrast? return? variation? overall shape? specific forms?

Return to top


III. Final Paper Preparation

Peer Review Exercise

In this peer review exercise, two other students in this course will read the complete 1st draft of your final paper and evaluate it. Further, you will read and evaluate final paper first drafts written by two other students in this course. Here’s how it works.

To get reviews of the 1st draft of your final paper:

  1. Find two other students in this course to read your first draft and evaluate it.
    • As a practical matter, asking two students from your Presentation Group helps guarantee that every student can easily evaluate first drafts for two other students.
  2. Send them your complete first draft and ask them to use this link to download the Paper Peer Review Form.
  3. Those two students will read your paper, fill out the Paper Peer Review Form, and email the form to you and to the instructor.

To review 1st drafts of final papers by two other students:

  1. Two other students in this course (probably from your Presentation Group) will ask you to read their first draft and evaluate it.
  2. You will say “Yes, of course!” You will then click this link twice to download two copies the Paper Peer Review Form.
  3. For each 1st draft you read, fill out a Paper Peer Review Form and email the form to the paper’s author and to the instructor.
The deadline for completing your first draft, getting it evaluated by two other students, and for evaluating papers by two other students is Monday, December 7th. It’s a good idea to complete your first draft a couple of days before the 7th to allow your peer reviewers time to read your paper and fill out the form. Please let me know if you have any questions.

You can find answers to many questions on the Final Paper web page.

Thinking ahead to the next step—The final draft of your paper is due on Friday, December 11th!

Return to top


Listening Assignment 6

The Mid-Baroque & Late Baroque Masters

Final Exam Listening Parts 1a & 1b
Final Exam Listening Part 2
Study Questions
Encounter 6 Listening List

Notes on the Final Exam

Final Exam Listening/Score Excerpts—Parts 1a & 1b

In these sections you will see score pages from works on the Exam List in the Study Guide on Blackboard. This list includes both mid- and late Baroque works from Encounter 6. It breaks down into two sections—Part 1a includes opera and other vocal genres; Part 1b focuses on instrumental genres. (For further information on vocal genres, please see the Baroque Vocal Genres Listening Guide.) I will test you on each list separately. For each work you hear, you will identify:

  • Composer & title (and section or movement, where necessary)
  • Genre
    • Part 1a: Vocal Genres—church cantata, intermezzo, opera, oratorio, or tragédie lyrique
    • Part 1b: Instrumental Genres—chorale prelude, concerto grosso, fugue, solo concerto, prelude, solo sonata (da chiesa or da camera), toccata, trio sonata (da chiesa or da camera), or solo concerto
  • Appropriate vocal or instrumental category
    • Part 1a: Vocal types—accompanied recitative, chorale, chorus, da capo aria, French overture, ground bass aria, simple recitative, or verse-refrain aria
    • Part 1b: Instrumental forms—allemande, canzona-like, courante, French overture, fugue, gigue, passacaglia, ritornello form, sarabande
  • Country of origin—England, France, Germany, or Italy
  • Two additional features—possible things to describe include:
    • Performing forces (solo voice(s)? chorus? solo instrument? continuo or orchestral accompaniment? etc.)
    • Examples of text depiction and text expression
    • Recurring rhythmic or metric patterns (describe them, please)
    • Texture (melody & accompaniment? homorhythmic? imitative? for which phrases?)
    • Use of ritornello, ground bass, or other distinctive formal features
    • Melodic style and use of ornamentation
    • etc.

For the complete Exam List, both Parts 1a and 1b, see the Final Exam Study Guide in the Blackboard Assignment Resources module.

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Final Exam Listening/Score Excerpts—Part 2

For the second Listening/Score Excerpts section of the Final Exam you will see NAWM score pages from three musical works, one each from the Middle Ages, Renaissance, and Baroque eras. You can prepare for this section by looking at scores and listening to representative works from NAWM, reflecting on the differences between these eras, and making lists of the most important style features for each era. Consider the following musical elements as you prepare.

  1. Texture types favored in each era—monophonic? melody & accompaniment? homorhythmic? imitative? fugal? etc.
  2. Nature of musical expression in each era—what did composers try to express? was text depiction/expression used or not?
  3. Important genres in each era—plainchant? organum? motet? Mass? madrigal? chanson? opera? oratorio? cantata? recitative? aria? chorus? etc.
  4. Other important style features—how does each era use – rhythm and meter? chromaticism? melodic shape & length? text setting (melismatic or syllabic? good declamation?) performing forces? dramatic features? etc.
  5. Important composers and dates for each era?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Study Questions

The best way to do well on quizzes, exams, and other assignments in this course is to know the assigned listening well. Listen to each work below as often as you can, study the scores, and learn what the NAWM notes say about each one. For each work you want to be able to answer the following Study Questions:

  • What is the genre?
  • What is its form?
  • What is the name of the style in which it is written?
  • How does this work use the elements of music? What features of the work are typical of the style? What features are not?
    • To answer this, look at the ways these works use melody, harmony, rhythm, dynamics, texture, color (timbre), form, text setting, and so on
  • How does the work compare with other works in the listening assignment (especially those in the same genre)?
  • What features of the work are unique or unusual?
  • For this encounter, pay special attention to:
    • In vocal works, what are the important differences between recitative, arioso, aria, and chorus? Consider especially the use of rhythm, performing forces, and melody.
    • What are the important similarities and differences between vocal genres such as opera, oratorio, cantata, and so on? Which vocal types and features are used in each genre? Which are unique to a particular genre?
    • What are the important features of a da capo aria? What are the main section in da capo form? How is the final A section different from the first A section?
    • What are the essential differences between performance practice in France and in Italy?
    • What are the important features of popular Baroque dance types (allemande, courante (or corrente), sarabande, gigue, gavotte, and so on)? Consider tempo, meter, rhythmic features, texture, etc. In what genres and works (on the Listening List below) can we find examples of these dances and dance rhythms?
    • Several multi-movement instrumental genres emerged in the Baroque era. What are the standard movement formats for mid- and late Baroque sonatas and concertos? What are the important differences between sonatas and concertos written for church and for chamber.
    • What role does continuo play in mid- and late Baroque music?
    • What is the “Doctrine of the Affections”? What specific techniques did Baroque composers use to express specific emotions?

In some cases, additional Study Questions below will draw attention to particularly interesting, unique features of specific works. These Study Questions, NAWM scores, and recordings together will help you prepare for the Final Exam. They require no written report.

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Encounter 6 Listening List

Before you listen, do the Burkholder readings above to familiarize yourself with the composers, their works, mid- and late-Baroque genres, and significant style features. Further readings listed below under Dances and Dance Suites and The Sonata for Church and Chamber will help you prepare for both the Encounter 5 Group Presentations and the Final Exam. Challenge yourself to identify musical features described in these sources as you listen and study these scores. The listening materials below will give you practice recognizing these works, genres, and their style features. As always with any NAWM work, you really want to read the NAWM notes, listen to the recording, and follow the score.

Cantata & Oratorio

A1) NAWM 80—Giacomo Carissimi, Historia di Jephte (Italian Oratorio)

  • a) Plorate colles (Recitative with arioso passages)
  • b) Plorate filii Israel (Chorus)

A2) NAWM 87—Marc-Antoine Charpentier, Le reniement de Saint Pierre, conclusion (French Oratorio)

  • a) Ministri ergo Judeorum (Narration and dialogue in recitative)
  • b) Et introductus est Petrus in domum (Chorus)
  • c) Et tu cum Jesu Nazareno eras? (Recitative and quartet)
  • d) Tunc respixit Jesus (Chorus)

A3) NAWM 94—Alessandro Scarlatti, Clori vezzosa, e bella, conclusion (Italian secular Cantata)

  • a) Vivo penando (Recitative)
  • b) Sì, sì ben mio (Da capo aria)

Study Question on Group A:

  1. Based on the excerpts above, what are the most obvious similarities and differences between mid-Baroque Italian cantatas and oratorios?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Mid Baroque Opera

B1) NAWM 85—Jean-Baptiste Lully, Armide (Tragédie lyrique—Mid Baroque French opera)

  • a) Overture (French overture)
  • b) Act II, scene 4
    • Laissons au tendre amour (Divertissement)
  • c) Act II, scene 5
    • Enfin il est en ma puissance (Recitative)

B2) NAWM 90—Henry Purcell, Dido and Aeneas, Act III, scene 2 (Mid Baroque English opera)

  • a) Thy hand, Belinda (Recitative)
  • b) When I am laid in earth (Ground bass aria)

B3) NAWM 93—Antonio Sartorio, Giulio Cesare in Egitto, Act II, Scenes 3-4 (Mid Baroque Italian opera)

  • a) Scene 3. Mostra Cleopatra (Recitative)
  • b) Se qualcuna mi bramasse (Da capo aria)
  • c) Scene 4. Son prigioniero (Written out Da capo aria)
  • d) Vaga Lidia, ove sei? (Trio)
  • e) Alla carcere d’un crine (Aria)

B4) NAWM 95—Alessandro Scarlatti, La Griselda, excerpt from Act I, Scene 2 (Mid Baroque Italian opera)

  • a) In voler ciò che tu brami (Da capo aria)

B5) NAWM 100—Jean-Philippe Rameau, Hippolyte et Aricie, Act IV conclusion (Tragédie lyrique—Late Baroque French opera)

Study Questions on Group B:

  1. What typical features of a French overture do you find in the Ouverture from Lully’s Armide? Consider its form as well as contrasts in texture, tempo, meter, etc.
  2. How do these French, Italian, and English examples of recitatives and arias differ from each other? What qualities seem particularly French, Italian, or English? Why?
  3. How is the final A section different from the first A section in the da capo arias from the Sartorio and Scarlatti operas?
  4. What is unusual about Rameau’s use of recitative, aria, chorus, and orchestra in this scene from Hippolyte et Aricie? How does the impact of this scene compare with that of the other opera examples here?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Dances and Dance Suites

Before listening to these works, read the following passages in your textbook:

  • The material on performance practice, especially notes inégales and overdotting, pp. 348-350
  • The section on Lute and Keyboard Music, especially the paragraphs on “Agréments” and “Style luthé,” pp. 352-353
  • The section on Dance Music, especially the paragraphs on “Binary form,” “Suites” (particularly its descriptions of individual dances), and “German versus French suites,” pp. 353-358

For each dance mentioned on pp. 355-358 (in boldface), make a short list (for your own use) of typical features (tempo, rhythm, upbeat, form, etc.)

Also browse through the following readings from the RESERVE list.

  • Mattheson, Johann, Der vollkommene Kapellmeister
    • Part I, Chapter 3, Sections 49-83, pp. 103-110
    • Part II, Chapter 13, Sections 79-142, pp. 451-468

Early Baroque sources used the terminlogy of rhetoric (the art and craft of persuasive speech, practiced by orators and actors) to explain how composers could express an emotion by imitating the speech patterns associated with that emotional state. Later in the Baroque period, notions of how to express and move the affections evolved into a deeper, more “scientific” system known as the Affektenlehre (Doctrine of the Affections). One of the principal sources of information about the Affektenlehre is Mattheson’s Der vollkommene Kapellmeister. Based on scientific writings on the nature of the affections, Mattheson’s book takes the six primary affections listed by Descartes and discusses the musical devices appropriate to express each one (see pp. 103-110). Mattheson goes even further, indicating that each musical genre, whether instrumental (see pp. 451-468) or vocal (see pp. 431-448), is naturally suited to the expression of some specific affection.

C1) NAWM 88—Denis Gaultier, La Coquette virtuose (French lute courante)

C2) NAWM 89—Elisabeth-Claude Jacquet de la Guerre, Suite No. 3 in A Minor, from Pièces de clavecin, Book I (French keyboard dance suite)

  • a) Prelude
  • b) Allemande
  • c) Courante I
  • d) Sarabande
  • e) Gigue

C3) NAWM 99—François Couperin, Vingt-cinquième ordre (French keyboard dance suite)

  • a) La visionaire (French overture)
  • b) La muse victorieuse (Passepied)

Study Questions on Group C:

  1. What features of French Baroque performance practice and keyboard style can you hear in the works above (based on the readings from pp. 348-350)? Find a few good examples.
  2. Practice listening for typical features of each dance as described on textbook pp. 355-358. For each dance above, which features (from the list you made—see instructions above) can you hear?
  3. Does the “affect” (emotion) of each dance above correspond to Mattheson’s description in his Der vollkommene Kapellmeister (RESERVE)? Browse through pp. 451-468 to find Mattheson’s descriptions of the dance-types used in these three suites and figure out how each dance fits (or doesn’t fit) his description.

Return to top
Return to listening menu

The Sonata for Church and Chamber

Before you listen, use Burkholder Ch. 17 (pp. 377-383) and either the Corelli lecture notes or the Baroque Sonata Listening Guide to determine characteristic features of Corelli’s sonatas, including the number and order of movements (for both church and chamber sonatas) as well as the typical form, tempo, meter, rhythms, and character for each movement. Make sure you understand the differences between the sonata da chiesa (church sonata) and the sonata da camera (chamber sonata) and between solo sonatas and trio sonatas. This will help you prepare for both the Encounter 5 Group Presentations and the final exam.

Trio Sonatas

D1) NAWM 96—Arcangelo Corelli, Trio Sonata in D, Op. 3, No. 2 (Church sonata)

  • a) Mvmt. I. Grave (Allemande)
  • b) Mvmt. II. Allegro (Fugue)
  • c) Mvmt. III. Adagio (Sarabande)
  • d) Mvmt. IV. Allegro (Gigue)
    • Alternate Recording: Purcell Quartet (with ornamentation!) – Assignment Resources module/Encounter Listening/Encounter 6/Corelli Trio Sonata, Op. 3, No. 2

Solo Sonatas

D2) Corelli, Sonatas for Solo Violin, Op. 5 CDs—RESERVE MCD C824/5m

  • Arcangelo Corelli, Violin Sonata, Op. 5, No. 10 (Chamber sonata)—CD2, tracks 13-17
    • Mvmt. I. Preludio. Adagio
    • Mvmt. II. Allemanda. Allegro
    • Mvmt. III. Sarabanda. Largo
    • Mvmt. IV. Gavotta. Allegro
    • Mvmt. V. Giga. Allegro
  • Alternate Recording—See Assignment Resources module/Encounter Listening/Encounter 6/Corelli Violin Sonata, Op. 5, No. 10

Study Questions on Group D:

  1. Identify important style features in each sonata movement above. How would you describe each movement’s use of melody, rhythm (tempo? meter? anacrusis? dotted or continuos rhythms?), texture (imitative? homophonic? other?), form (binary? fugal?), dance type (use the lists you made for Dances & Dance Suites above), and instrumentation (how many violins? continuo instruments?).
  2. What are the most important differences between church sonatas and chamber sonatas?
  3. What are the most important differences between solo sonatas and trio sonatas (besides the number of violins used)?
  4. Does the “affect” (emotion) of each dance in the Corelli chamber sonata correspond to Mattheson’s description in his Der vollkommene Kapellmeister (RESERVE)? Browse through pp. 451-468 to find Mattheson’s descriptions of the dance-types used in these sonatas and figure out how each dance fits (or doesn’t fit) his description.
  5. These Corelli sonatas provide excellent examples of Italian Baroque style. Based on the Peter le Huray reading and your observations on the examples in Groups C and D, what do you hear as the chief differences between Italian Baroque and French Baroque styles?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Late Baroque Opera and Oratorio in England

Italian Opera in England

E1) NAWM 107—George Frideric Handel, Giulio Cesare (Italian opera)

  • Act II, scenes 1-2
    • a) Scene 1. Eseguisti, oh Niren (Recitative)
    • b) Scene 2. Da Cleopatra apprenda (Recitative with Sinfonia)
    • c) V’adoro pupille (Da capo aria)

Handel & the English Oratorio

E2) NAWM 108—George Frideric Handel, Saul (English oratorio)

  • a) No. 66. The Time at length is come (Accompanied recitative)
  • b) No. 67. Where is the Son of Jesse? (Simple recitative)
  • c) No. 68. O Fatal Consequence of Rage (Chorus)

E3) Messiah DVD—RESERVE VIDEO 781.7 H236m

  • George Frideric Handel, Messiah (English oratorio)
    • There were shepherds (Simple recitative & accompanied recitative)—DVD track 14
    • Glory to God (Chorus)—DVD track 15
  • Alternate Recording: Naxos Music Library 8.550667-68—Handel, The Messiahtracks 14-15

Study Questions on Group E:

  1. How would you describe the differences between Handel’s operas and his oratorios?
  2. Based on these Handel examples, what are the primary differences between simple (continuo) recitative, accompanied recitative, and arias in the late Baroque? How does Handel combine these types effectively in his “scene complexes” (see textbook pp. 445-446)? What does Handel do to alter the “recit-aria-recit-aria-etc.” formula of previous Baroque operas?
  3. How effectively do these late Baroque arias and choruses express the text? What techniques does Handel use?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Early Classic Opera before 1750

NOTE: These Group F examples are in NAWM Vol. 2! Go to Encounter Listening in Blackboard to find recordings of these works.

F1) NAWM 109—Giovanni Battista Pergolesi, La serva padrona (Intermezzo)—Blackboard RESERVE

  • a) Ah, quanto mi sta male (Simple & accomponaied recitative)
  • b) Son imbrogliato io (da capo aria)

F2) NAWM 110—Johann Adolf Hasse, Cleofide (Italian opera seria)—Blackboard RESERVE

  • Act II, scene 9: Digli ch’io son fidele (Da capo aria)

F3) NAWM 111—Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Le devin du village, Scene 1 (French opéra comique)—Blackboard RESERVE

F4) NAWM 112—John Gay, The Beggar’s Opera (English ballad opera)—Blackboard RESERVE

  • Aria XV: My heart was so free (Aria)
  • Aria XVI: Were I laid on Greenland’s coast (Aria)

Study Question on Group F:

  1. What are the important differences between Italian comic opera, Italian opera seria, French opéra comique, and English ballad opera? Consider form, melodic features, ornamentation, subject matter, language, instrumentation, rhythm, texture, and so on.

Return to top
Return to listening menu

The Mid Baroque Concerto

G1) Corelli Concerti Grossi Op. 6 Nos. 7-12 CD—Blackboard RESERVE

  • Concerto Grosso in G Minor, Op. 6, No. 8, Fatto per la notte di natale (written for Christmas Eve) (Concerto grosso da chiesa)
    • II. Allegro (allemande in binary form)
    • Vb. Largo. Pastorale ad libitum (pastorale)

The Late Baroque Concerto

G2) NAWM 98—Antonio Vivaldi, Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in A Minor, Op. 3, No. 6 (Violin concerto)

  • a) I. Allegro (Ritornello form)
  • b) II. Largo
  • c) III. Presto (Ritornello form)
    • Alternate Recording: L’estro armonico CD set, Fabio Biondi & Europa Galante—Blackboard RESERVE

G3) Johann Sebastian Bach, Brandenburg Concertos DVD—RESERVE VIDEO 784.2 B817f

  • Concerto No. 5 in D Major (Concerto grosso)—DVD Side B, chapter 4
    • I. Allegro (Ritornello form)
  • Alternate Recording: RESERVE MCD B118/1046n—Bach, Brandenburg Concertos—CD2, track 4
  • Alternate Recording: Six Concertos for the Margrave of Brandenburg CD set, European Brandenburg Ensemble, Trevor Pinnock, cond.—Blackboard RESERVE

Study Questions on Group G:

  1. Based on the examples above, what are the important differences between mid and late Baroque concertos?
  2. Which movements of these concertos generally use ritornello form: I, II, and/or III?
  3. Outside of tempo, what differences do you hear between slow movements and fast movements in these concertos? Consider form, performing forces, and any other features that stand out.
  4. Based on the examples above, what are the important differences between Bach’s music and Vivaldi’s? Any style features are fair game in your comparison.

Return to top
Return to listening menu

The North German Organ School

Quasi-Improvisatory and Imitative Works

H1) NAWM 97—Dietrich Buxtehude, Praeludium in E Major (Mid Baroque organ prelude)

    • Alternate Recording—See Assignment Resources module/Encounter Listening/Encounter 6/Buxtehude, Praeludium in E Major

H2) NAWM 102—Johann Sebastian Bach, Prelude and Fugue in A Minor (Organ prelude and fugue)

  • a) Prelude
  • b) Fugue

H3) Development of Western Music (DWMA)—RESERVE MCD D489 1998

  • DWMA 116—Johann Sebastian Bach, Das wohltemperirte Klavier, Prelude and Fugue in C minor, BWV 847 (Keyboard prelude and fugue)—CD6, tracks 18-19
    • Alternate Recording: RESERVE VIDEO 786.2 B118j—Bach, 48 Preludes and Fugues: The Well-Tempered Clavier—DVD 1
    • Alternate Recording—See Assignment Resources module/Encounter Listening/Encounter 6/Bach Prelude & Fugue

Chorale-Based Works

H4) NAWM 103—Johann Sebastian Bach, Durch Adams Fall, BWV 637 (Chorale prelude)

Study Questions on Group H:

  1. Why did Buxtehude write just a prelude and not a prelude and fugue? Are there any fugal sections in this work? How would you describe the use of imitative sections here?
  2. Late Baroque composers frequently paired improvisatory works (toccatas, preludes, fantasias, etc.) with fugues. What effect is created by pairing an improvisatory work and a fugue? How similar or different are the Bach organ toccata and the Bach WTC keyboard prelude above?
  3. Which term best describes the Bach chorale prelude, Durch Adams Fall—imitative, ornamental, or figural (see Burkholder, pp. 395-396)? What is the effect of the descending 7th motive in the pedals? What musical motives and techniques does Bach use to symbolize the central image of the title, Adam’s fall from grace (“original sin”)?

Return to top
Return to listening menu

Bach Vocal Music

I1) NAWM 105—Johann Sebastian Bach, Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland, BWV 62 (Church cantata)

  1. Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland (Chorus—in the form of a “gapped” chorale prelude)
  2. Bewundert, o Menschen (Full da capo aria)
  3. So geht aus Gottes Herrlichkeit und Thron (Recitative)
  4. Streite, siege, starker Held! (Full da capo aria)
  5. Wir ehren diese Herrlichkeit (Accompanied recitative)
  6. Lob sei Gott, dem Vater, ton (Chorale)

I2) NAWM 106—Johann Sebastian Bach, St. Matthew Passion, BWV 244 (Passion)

  • No. 36, Und der Hohenpriester antwortete (Biblical narrative with dry recitative, accompanied recitative, and chorus)
  • No. 37, Wer hat dich so geschlagen (Chorale)
  • No. 38, Petrus aber saß draußen im Palast (Biblical narrative with dry recitative and chorus)
  • No. 39, Erbarme dich (Aria)
  • No. 40, Bin ich gleich von dir gewichen (Chorale)

Study Questions on Group I:

  1. What are the most important differences between this Bach church cantata & passion and the Handel opera & oratorio excerpts in Group E above? Pay special attention to the types of musical numbers used (aria, recitative, chorus, chorale) and the ways Bach uses them. Does the fact that Bach wrote these works for church explain any of the differences? What role does the chorale melody Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland play in the cantata? What role do chorales play in the St. Matthew Passion?
  2. Study Bach’s opening chorus in the cantata. Bach often combines features of contrasting genres in his choruses, and this one is no exception. Here he fuses the chorale motet with the ritornello form typical of a concerto. How is this an example of ritornello form? Where are the ritornello statements? Where are the episodes? How does Bach present phrases from the cantus firmus (Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland) in this chorus? In what ways does his use of the cantus firmus resemble the way Josquin used pre-existing melodies in his Masses and motets? Can you find examples of fore-imitation here? Where? What similarities and differences do you find between this chorus and our Handel chorus (Glory to God) from Messiah? How does this cantata chorus compare with Bach’s use of the chorus in the Biblical narratives from St. Matthew Passion?
  3. As you compare vocal music by Handel and Bach (Groups E and I), which composer is more obvious in using text depiction? Which one is more obvious in using musical symbolism? Which one relies more heavily on contrapuntal textures? Which one uses contrasting textures and dynamics more dramatically? Where can you find good examples of these features?

Return to top
Return to listening menu


Extra Credit Listening—

Buehler Library RESERVE

  • MCD C824/1—Corelli, Sonate da chiesa, Op. 1 & 3 (London Baroque)
  • MCD C824/5m—Corelli, Sonatas for Solo Violin, Op. 5 (Andrew Manze)
  • MCD H236/016j—Handel, Giulio Cesare—Highlights (Jacobs)
  • VIDEO 781.7 H236m—Handel, Messiah DVD (Cleobury)
  • MCD V855/8h—Vivaldi, The Four Seasons CD (Hogwood)
  • MCD B118/1046n—Bach, Brandenburg Concertos (Pickett)
  • VIDEO 784.2 B817f—Bach, Brandenburg Concertos DVD (von der Goltz)
  • MCD B118/565tk—Bach, Toccata & Fugue (Koopman)
  • VIDEO 786.5 B118o—Bach, Greatest Organ Works, Volume One DVD (Stamm)
  • VIDEO 786.2 B118j—Bach, 48 Preludes and Fugues: The Well Tempered Clavier DVD (Gavrilov, MacGregor, Demidenko, and Hewitt)
  • MCD B118/248k—Bach, Weinachts-Oratorium (Christmas Oratorio) (Koopman)
  • MCD B118/244k—Bach, Matthäus-Passion (St. Matthew Passion) (Koopman)
  • MCD D489 1998—Development of Western Music recordings (DWMA), 3rd edition, Volume I, CD5-CD6
    • DWMA 104a—Samuel Scheidt, Vater unser im Himmelreich (Imitative Chorale Prelude)—CD5, track 7
    • DWMA 104b—Dietrich Buxtehude, Vater unser im Himmelreich (Ornamental Chorale Prelude)—CD5, track 8
    • DWMA 104d—Johann Sebastian Bach, Vater unser im Himmelreich (Figural Chorale Prelude)—CD5, track 9
    • DWMA 114—Johann Sebastian Bach, Cantata No. 80: Ein’ feste Burg ist unser Gott, Mvmt. I (Cantata excerpt)—CD6, track 15
    • DWMA 118—George Frideric Handel, Giulio Cesare–Act III, scene 7 (Late Baroque Italian Opera excerpt)—CD6, track 21
    • DWMA 119a—George Frideric Handel, Messiah, “Comfort ye” (Accompanied Recitative—Oratorio excerpt)—CD6, track 22
    • DWMA 119b—George Frideric Handel, Messiah, “Every valley”(Aria—Oratorio excerpt)—CD6, track 23
    • DWMA 119c—George Frideric Handel, Messiah, “And the glory of the Lord”(Chorus—Oratorio excerpt)—CD6, track 24


Created 9/12/20 by Mark Harbold—last updated 11/19/20